Astounding Science Fiction Stories Vol 1, page 780
"Tigers," Ward said. Standing beside Allenby, he felt very tall, although he was only of average height. He smoothed down his wiry dark hair and began energetically brushing the dust from his clothing.
"Well, it's always something," Allenby said tiredly.
He seemed more sad than upset, Ward thought, a spent old man clinging to the straw of a dream. He saw where the metaphor was leading and pushed it aside. If Allenby were a drowning man, then Ward himself was one. He looked at the others.
They were all edgy or simply frightened, but they were taking it very well. Some of them were stationed at the gates of the Quad, but none of them, as far as he could see, was armed. Except for McCarthy. The psych man was wearing his Star Watcher helmet and had a B-gun strapped at his side. Probably had a small force-field in his pocket, Ward thought, and a pair of brass knuckles.
"So--the philosophy king got it too," McCarthy said, coming over to them. He was a big man, young but already florid with what Ward had always thought of as a roan complexion. "Love, understanding, sympathy--wasn't that what was supposed to work wonders? All they need is a copy of Robinson Crusoe and a chance to follow their natural instincts, eh?"
"One failure doesn't prove anything," Ward said, trying not to be angry.
"One failure? How often do they have to make us hit the slides for the safety of the Mob Quad before you adopt a sensible theory?"
"Let's not go through all that again. Restraint, Rubber hoses and Radiological shock--I've heard all about the 3 Rs."
"At least they work!"
"Oh, yes, they work fine. Except that they never learn to read and they can't sign their names with anything but an X."
"It was progressive education that destroyed reading," McCarthy said heatedly. "And they don't need to sign their names--that's what universal fingerprinting is for."
"Please, gentlemen," Dr. Allenby interrupted gently. "This kind of squabbling is unbecoming to members of the faculty. Besides," he smiled with faded irony, "considering the circumstances, it's hardly a proper time."
He pointed to the windows over the Quad where an occasional figure could be seen behind the glass. Lucky it was unbreakable, Ward thought, hearing the wild hysterical yelling from inside.
"Mob Quad," Allenby said bitterly. "I thought I was naming it as a joke. The original Mob Quad was at Merton College, Oxford. One of the old defunct universities. They had a Mob Quad to shelter students and professors from the town mobs. Professors and students, gentlemen--they were a united front in those days. I suppose no one could have predicted our present circumstances."
"That's all history," McCarthy said impatiently. "Bunk. This is now, and I say the thing to do--"
"We know." Allenby waved him to silence. "But your way has been tried long enough. How long is it since Los Angeles Day, when the U.N. buildings were bombed and burned by the original 3R Party in order to get rid of Unesco? Two hundred forty-three years next June, isn't it? And your Party had had all that time to get education back on what it calls a sane program. Now nobody is educated."
"It takes time to undo the damage of progressive education," McCarthy said. "Besides, a lot of that junk--reading, writing--as I've often told Ward--"
"All right," Ward broke in. "But two and a half centuries is long enough. Someone must try a new tack or the country is doomed. There isn't much time. The Outspace invaders--"
"The Outspace invaders are simply Russians," McCarthy said flatly.
"That's a convenient view if you're an ostrich. Or, if you want to keep the Pretend War going, until the Outspacers take us over."
McCarthy snorted contemptuously. "Ward, you damned fool--"
"That will be all, gentlemen," Allenby said. He did not raise his voice, but McCarthy was silent and Ward marveled, as he had on other occasions, at the authority the old man carried.
"Well," McCarthy said after a moment, "what are you going to do about this?" He gestured toward the windows from which shouts still rang.
"Nothing. Let it run its course."
"But you can't do that, man!"
"I can and I will. What do you think, John?"
"I agree," Ward said. "They won't hurt each other--they never have yet. It'll wear itself out and then, tomorrow, we'll try again." He did not feel optimistic about how things would be the next day, but he didn't want to voice his fears. "The thing that worries me," he said, "are those tigers. Where'd they come from?"
"What tigers?" McCarthy wanted to know.
Ward told him.
"First it was cats," McCarthy said, "then birds ... now tigers. Either you're seeing things or someone's using a concealed projector."
"I thought of the projector, but these seemed real. Stunned at first--as if they were as surprised as I was."
"You have a teleport in your class," Allenby said.
"Yes--maybe that's the way it was done. I don't know quite what to make of it," Ward said. If he voiced his real suspicion now, he knew it would sound silly. "I know some of them can teleport. I've seen them. Small things, of course...."
"Not in my classes," McCarthy said indignantly. "I absolutely forbid that sort of thing."
"You do wrong, then," Allenby said.
"It's unscientific!"
"Perhaps. But we want to encourage whatever wild talents they possess."
"So that they can materialize tigers in--in our bedrooms, I suppose. Well, I've had enough. Stay here and stew if you like, but I'm going back to my class. I turned the hypno-gas on them before I took my dive. They should be nice and gentle for me by this time." He turned away defiantly.
"I know how you feel," Allenby said when McCarthy was gone. "He's a holy terror, John. Shouldn't be around here. But I have to keep him, since he was recommended by the 3Rs and the Educational League. He gives the school a bit of protective coloration. Perhaps he's why they haven't closed us down yet."
"I know--I'm not blaming you. Do you suppose we can go back to our jobs? It sounds as if it's wearing itself out." He gestured up at the windows.
"Can't do anything more today."
"No, you're probably right."
* * * * *
For a moment Allenby was silent as they went toward the gate of the Quad. Then he said, "John, you're a good man. I don't want you to despair. What we're attempting--to bring education back into our culture--is a good and noble cause. And you can't really blame the kids." He nodded up at the walls. "They've just had too many Spellcasts, too many scares in the Pretend War--they can't believe in any future and they don't know anything about their past. Don't blame them."
"No, sir--I don't."
"Just do our best," Allenby said. "Try to teach them the forgotten things. Then, in their turn, in the next generation...."
"Yes, we have to believe that. But, Dr. Allenby, we could go a lot faster if we were to screen them. If they were all like young Tomkins, we'd be doing very well. But as long as we have people like young Cress or Hodge or Rottke--well, it's hard to do anything with them. They go straight from school into their fathers' firms--after all, if you're guaranteed a business success in life, you don't struggle to learn. And, anyway, you don't need much education to be a dope salesman or a numbers consultant."
"I'd like to have the place run only for the deserving and the interested," Allenby said. "But we haven't much choice. We must have some of these boys who are from the best families. More protective coloration--like McCarthy. If we were only to run the place for the brilliant ones, you know we'd be closed down in a week."
"I suppose so," Ward agreed. He wondered whether he should tell his suspicions to Allenby. Better not, he decided. Allenby had enough to think about.
The last of the shouting had died. As Ward went out the gate of the Quad, he felt his heart lift a little the way it always did when he started for home. Out here, miles from the city, the air was clean and the Sun was bright on the hills, quilted now with the colors of autumn. There was a tang of wood smoke in the air and, in the leaves beside the path, he saw an apple. It was very cold and damp and there was a wild taste to it as he bit into the fruit. He was a tired teacher, glad to be going home after a hard day in the school. He hoped that no one had been hurt by the tigers.
* * * * *
John Ward pushed the papers across his desk, reached for his pipe and sighed. "Well, that does it, Bobby," he said.
He looked at the red-headed six-year-old boy sitting in the too-big chair across from him. Bobby was a small boy with a freckled face and skinned knees. He sat in the big chair with his feet sticking straight out in front of him and played with a slide rule.
"I've taught you all the math I know," Ward said. "Differential, integral, topology, Maddow's Theory of Transfinite Domains--that's as far as I go. What's next?"
"I don't know, John. I was thinking of going in for nuclear physics, but...."
"Go on, but what?" Ward prompted.
"Well...." Bobby gave him an embarrassed look. "I'm kind of tired of that stuff. It's easy and not very interesting. What I'd really like--" He broke off and began fiddling with the slide rule again.
"Yes, Bobby, what would you like?"
"You won't be mad?"
"No." Ward smiled.
"Well, I'd really like to try to write a poem--a real poem, I mean, not advertiverse--a real poem, with rhymes and everything." He paused and looked to see how Ward was taking it and then went on with a rush. "I know it's almost illegal, but I want to try. I really want to."
"But why?"
"Oh, I dunno--I just want to. I remember that an old poet named Yeats said something about writing poems--the fascination with what's difficult. Maybe that's it."
"Well," Ward said, "it's a dangerous occupation." He looked at the boy with wonder and pride. "Sure, Bobby, give it a try if you want to."
"Gee, thanks!" the boy said. He jumped out of the chair and started toward the door of the study.
"Bobby," Ward called. "Tell me--can you teleport?"
"Not exactly," Bobby said. The papers on the desk in front of Ward suddenly fluttered into the air. They did a lazy circle of the room, swung into an echelon and performed a slow chandelle, before dropping into Bobby's hand. "I can do that stuff. But I didn't do the tigers."
"I'm sure you didn't."
"It was a good stunt, but I wouldn't do that to you, John."
"I know. Do you know who did?"
"I'm not sure." Bobby didn't look at him now. "Anyway, it'd be snitching."
"I'm not asking you to tell."
"Gee, I'm sorry," Bobby said. "I wanted to tell you in the yard. I knew there was going to be a rumble, but I couldn't snitch."
"No, of course not." Ward shooed him off. "Go write your poem."
* * * * *
"But tigers!" Ann said. "Why tigers, John?"
"I suppose they were convenient."
"Tigers are never convenient."
He crossed the room, picked up the phone and dialed. After a brief conversation, he turned back to her. "Well, now we know where they came from," he said. "The zoo. Disappeared for about half an hour. Then reappeared again."
"I don't care where they came from," his wife said. Her dark head was bent over some work in her lap. "What difference does it make whether they came from the zoo or from Burma? The point is, bringing them in is dangerous--it's hooliganism, and don't tell me that boys will be boys."
"It doesn't show very mature judgment," he admitted. "But Bobby and his pals aren't very old."
"Only about four hundred and eighty-five years old, according to his I.Q. Do you think it was Bobby?"
"Bobby isn't the only genius we've got. There's Danny, remember, and William Tender--and Bobby said he couldn't teleport big stuff."
"Well?"
John Ward had to confide his theory. He felt that he had to tell Ann everything, all the speculation and suspicion he'd carried around with him for so long.
"I think we're being invaded," he said.
Ann looked at him steadily for a moment. "You mean the Outspacers?"
"Yes--but not in the way you're thinking. It's been reported that the Saucers are Russian or Argentine or Brazilian or Chinese--that's what we're told. But that's simply Pretend War propaganda and almost no one believes it any longer. Most of us think of them as Outspacers."
"And you think they're moving in?"
"I think they're watching--sort of--well, sort of monitoring."
"Monitoring us? What for?"
"No, not us. I think they've planted children among us. I think the Outspacers are school-teachers."
Ann got briskly to her feet. "I think," she said, "that we'll take your temperature and see if perhaps you shouldn't be in bed."
"Wait, Ann, I'm serious. I know it sounds crazy, but it isn't. Think of it this way--here's a race, obviously humanoid, on another star system. For some reason, overpopulation or whatever, they have to find room on another planet. Let's assume they're a highly civilized race--they'd have to be to have interstellar travel--so, of course, they can't simply take over Earth in an act of aggression. That would be repugnant to them.
"So they seed our planet with their children. These children are geniuses. When they grow up, they are naturally the leaders of the world's governments and they're in a position to allow the Outspacers to live with us on Earth. To live peacefully with us, whereas now, if the Outspacers were to try to live here, it would mean war."
"And you think Bobby is one of these--these seedlings?"
"Maybe. He's unbelievingly intelligent. And he's a foundling."
"What has that to do with it?"
"I've looked up the statistics on foundlings. When the Saucers first began to appear, back in the 20th Century, the number of foundlings began to increase. Not a lot, but some. Then the Saucers disappeared for almost two and a half centuries and the number decreased. Now, since the Outspacers are once more evident, the number of foundlings has increased very greatly."
"And your other geniuses? All foundlings?"
"Not all. But that doesn't mean anything--plenty of foundlings are adopted. And who knows which child is an adopted one?"
Ann Ward sat down again. "You're quite serious about this, John?"
"There's no way of being sure, but I am convinced."
"It's frightening."
"Is Bobby frightening? In all the time I've been tutoring him, has he ever been out of line?"
"Bobby's no alien!"
"He may be."
"Well, anyway, of course Bobby isn't frightening. But that business of the tigers--that is!"
"They didn't hurt anyone."
"No, but don't you see, John? It's--irresponsible. How do you fit it in with your super-intelligent super-beings?"
"Ann," he said impatiently, "we're dealing with fantastically intelligent beings, but beings who are still children--can't you understand that? They're just finding out their powers--one is a telepath, another levitates, a third is a teleport. A riot is started by Alec Cress or Jacky Hodge or one of those 3R hoodlums. And our child genius can't resist making a kind of joke of his own."
"Joke? With tigers? John, I tell you I'm frightened." Her husband said nothing and she looked at him sharply. "You hope it's this way, don't you?"
For a moment he didn't answer. Then he sighed. "Yes. Yes, I do both believe and hope I'm right, Ann. I never thought that I'd be willing to give up the struggle--that's what it amounts to. But I don't think the human race can manage itself any more. So, I'm willing and glad to have some other race teach us how to live. I know we've always looked on the idea of domination by some race from the stars with both terror and revulsion. But we've made such a mess of things on Earth that I, at least, would be glad to see them come."
After a while, Ann said, "I've got to do some shopping for supper."
She began mechanically putting her work away.
"You're shocked?"
"Yes. And relieved, too, a little. And, at the same time, still a bit frightened."
"It's probably for the best."
"Yes. It's sad, though. Have you told this to anyone else?"
"No. After all, it's still only a theory. I've got to find some kind of proof. Except that I don't know how."
"You've convinced me." She stood in the doorway, then turned to him and he could see that she was crying. She dashed the tears from her eyes. "I suppose we have to go on doing the same things. We have to have dinner tonight. I must shop...."
He took her in his arms. "It'll be all right," he said.
"I feel so helpless! What are you going to do?"
"Right now," he said, "I think I'll go fishing."
Ann began to laugh, a little hysterically. "You are relaxed about it," she said.
"Might as well relax and give it more thought."
Ann kissed him and went into the kitchen. She was gone when he came out with his rod and creel. Going down the walk under the trees, he was aware again of what a fine autumn afternoon it was. He began to whistle as he went down the hill toward the stream.
He didn't catch anything, of course. He had fished the pool at least a hundred times without luck, but that did not matter. He knew there was a fighting old bass in its depths and, probably, he would have been sorry to catch him. Now, his line gently agitated the dark water as he sat under a big tree on the stream bank and smoked. Idly he opened the copy of Yeats' poems and began reading: Turning and turning in the widening gyre....
In mounting excitement, he read the coldly beautiful, the terrible and revelatory poem through to the end. And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, slouches toward Bethlehem to be born?
Ward became aware that his pipe was out. He put it away, feeling the goose pimples, generated by the poem, leave his flesh. Then he shook himself and sighed. We're lucky, he thought, it might have been the way the old boy predicted it in the poem. It might have been terrible.
He sighed again, watching his line in the dark water, and thought of Bobby. You could hardly call Bobby a rough beast. The line flickered in the water and then was still. He would have a lot of time for this kind of life, he thought, if his theory were correct. He watched a flight of leaves dapple the pool with the insignia of autumn. He was not sure he wanted to spend a lifetime fishing.
