Only She Came Back, page 2
What makes a woman want to kill? I don’t think it should even be a question—don’t we have plenty of reasons?—but because it’s more rare, everyone wonders.
Sometimes being spurned by a man pushes a woman over the line. Sometimes it’s money. Sometimes despair. And sometimes she just wants payback for all the crap she’s had to put up with. My favorite example was Drea Flint, a twenty-one-year-old who started out by killing her stepfather, then joined up with an older boyfriend and cut a bloody swath across the Southwest, robbing a bunch of guys and leaving five truckers and a gas station attendant dead.
“Cut a bloody swath” is sensationalist language, my friend Lore would say. Lore was happy to watch Hannibal and Natural Born Killers with me, but look at crime scene photos? No way. And in junior year, when I told Lore about my podcast idea, they got all uptight about my “obsession.” Was I a murder hound? A police groupie? Did I know that murders of pretty white girls get disproportionate attention?
I knew all that, of course. I also knew that most murders aren’t mysteries at all, and the ones that do go cold rarely get solved. My podcast was not about being an armchair detective. I just hated how people talked online about Drea Flint, treating her as if she were sicker and more disgusting than her boyfriend, though he was just as abusive as the other men in her life. Nobody seemed to care that her stepfather used to beat her, or that her teachers remembered her as a talented poet, or that she couldn’t seem to shake her addiction to sleazebag guys who told her what to do. I wanted to tell all of her sad story.
In the end, I just didn’t have enough to tell. Or maybe the problem was how I told it, with my wobbly voice and crappy home recording setup. I was another clueless kid desperate to be part of the conversation, and when I realized the whole thing was embarrassing, I stopped. Soon after that, I met Reggie, so I didn’t mind being just a true-crime consumer. We’d swap our most horrendous murder stories at the Grand Nine, trying to gross or freak each other out and usually failing.
It gets boring just collecting stories, though. Deep down, I still wanted to be the one to tell a story no one else could.
By the time I’d watched all the essential videos in the Callum/Kiri saga, it was nearly 2:00 AM. But it was tough to sleep when everybody online was buzzing.
Was Kiri involved in Callum’s death? She had to be, right? (Have you seen those vids?)
Why’d the cops even let her fly back to Vermont? Shouldn’t they have held her in New Mexico for more questioning? What if she made a break for the Canadian border?
My fingertips itched, I wanted so badly to write my own comment. I know this girl! We went to high school together! After all my years of true-crime obsession, finally I knew a person of interest.
But what did I know, exactly? That Kiri/Katie was shy? That she used to have brown hair? I cringed at the thought of posting that.
So I just lay there between the sweaty sheets, scrolling and scrolling, listening to the happy laughter and zydeco beats that wafted across the parking lot from Molly B’s Bar & Grill. I switched from feed to feed, finding the influencers who had the most active comment sections, waiting for one of Katie’s friends or teammates to post real insider info. My shift the next day didn’t start until noon.
The more I read, the smaller and grubbier I felt. Between junior year and now, Katie Dunsmore had grown larger than life.
Maybe she’d gotten some earlier attention on the YouTube channel, but it was nothing compared with this. Whatever happened in the desert had made her every action and motive worthy of dissection—the tilt of her head, the way she wore her hair when she boarded the plane back to Vermont, the tone of voice she used to say, I think he’s dead.
It was partly because she was pretty—but not in a good way, people kept saying. Her eyes are so dead, several insisted.
So many people were already trying to spin the story the way they read it.
Her eyes? What about his?!
Callum’s an inspiration. If you don’t see that, you need to wake up.
Callum’s a perv. If Kiri didn’t ice him, she should’ve.
But if Katie really was a killer—I couldn’t assume that, of course—how had she become one from the person I had known? What was her story, and would she ever be able to tell it on her own terms?
People kept reposting the same still of Kiri and Callum standing arm in arm in the late desert sunlight. With matching dark sunglasses, gleaming teeth, and brilliant smiles, they were a movie poster. They felt immortal.
Aliza Deene of Murder Most F**ked Up, my favorite true-crime source, posted a video encouraging people to stop jumping to conclusions and wait for more evidence. That was typical Aliza: Instead of going for the most sensational angle, she tried to understand what made criminals tick. But it did no good: Everybody already had a take, had their assumptions.
She’s obvs mentally unstable.
He’s six years older. Classic grooming.
That doesn’t make it okay to kill him.
We don’t even know he’s dead!
She’s a sociopath. I can always tell.
Last call came and went at Molly B’s. At nearly three, I couldn’t take all the voices buzzing in my head anymore (look at her hair, look at her smile, look at her bitch face), so I got up quietly and locked the apartment and wheeled my bike down the steps to the pavement.
Aside from the groan of the four-lane highway just up the road, my neighborhood was dead quiet. Classic Burlington. There aren’t many houses around here, just warehouses and city utilities sitting in big patches of concrete and pools of orange light. I took the left turn away from Burton Snowboards and along the park, then into the woods, until I came out in a tiny neighborhood that curves around the lakeshore.
Katie’s house was as nice as I expected. It wasn’t right on the water, but it stood up away from the street with a good view: two stories, clean and modern, surrounded by placid globes of light. There was a window under the second-floor gable, facing the lake. Maybe that was hers.
I stood there in the middle of the street, holding my bike, thinking about how alone Katie—Kiri—must have felt in the desert and how alone I was now. Just me and the keening katydids and the dull clang, clang of a boat’s mast as the waves sloshed it back and forth. The winking lights on the far side of the lake cast a hazy glow that showed me the outlines of the Adirondacks.
Had I been envying Katie because she was famous for possibly committing a murder? Out here in the fresh air, closer to where she was hiding out, I didn’t feel good about that.
But it wasn’t like I had anything better to do. Should I be getting my beauty sleep so I could scoop popcorn for kiddies tomorrow? Reading community college catalogs? These days, “waste of space” kind of described me.
A mass of trees rose behind Katie’s house; the yard must back onto the park. I’d probably seen this house a million times from the other side, walking the trails, and never realized it was hers. Never had a reason to care.
I snapped a photo, careful not to use the flash. If I were an even bigger waste of space, I might have posted it: Hey, guess what, y’all? I’m outside Kiri Dunsmore’s house right now!
Instead, I kept it for myself. A wild plan was already forming in my head, and that plan required me to be more subtle. More cunning.
I hadn’t been able to tell Drea’s untold story because I didn’t know her. She’d died by suicide in prison, and all my sources were second- and third-hand accounts. But Katie’s story—I was close to it already, and maybe I could get closer.
Two days later, on my day off, I dug out some old running gear, biked to the park, locked up the bike, and “jogged” the trail behind Katie’s house. I’m no runner, so the best I could actually do was fast-walk most of the way.
When I reached the stretch of woods that I suspected adjoined her backyard, I did start running (slowly). It was a good thing, because up ahead stood a young guy wearing city clothes—nice jeans and a leather jacket—and talking into a headset. He leaned against one of the boulders on the other side of the trail. I ran past him and around the curve, forcing myself not to glance in the direction of her house.
Probably media, doing exactly what I was—monitoring the area for sightings. He was still there the second time I came around the loop, but not the third. I left the trail and did hamstring stretches while I chanced some glimpses through the screen of trees: a garden bright with zinnias and tiny tomatoes. A deck draped with colorful beach towels. A big slider window.
I did several more loops, dripping with sweat despite doing more walking than actual running. By then, it was nearly dinnertime, and the park was emptying out. I lingered opposite the house for twenty minutes, long enough to see flashes of TV inside and a skinny bald guy (Katie’s dad?) pacing the lawn, having an inaudible phone conversation.
But no Kiri—Katie. I kept having to remind myself to use the name I’d known her by, because Kiri wasn’t someone I knew yet, even if I wanted to think I did. Katie was my English classmate; Kiri lived on screens and might be a murderer.
Come out, Katie. Come out.
Should I text her? She was still in my contacts, but her inbox would be full of media people and old friends suddenly wanting to reconnect. I needed a reason, something plausible that had nothing to do with the case. I racked my brain.
Lore texted to ask if I wanted to hang at the waterfront. I texted back that I had community college enrollment paperwork to do.
You’re stalking her. You’re better than this. I could just see Lore saying that, shaking their head sadly. On the other hand, Brenna, my stepmom, wouldn’t be sad at all. To her, everything I’d done today would be proof of my unfitness for salvation in her high-class heaven, right in line with my punk T-shirts and my mom’s tattoos and the fact that I’d been watching R-rated movies since I was ten.
Sometimes I wonder if Brenna knows that Dad used to hit Mom while I cowered under the covers. Sometimes I wonder if she thinks it was Mom’s fault for not being the amazing wife that Brenna thinks she is.
Screw her. Screw everyone. I wasn’t hurting anyone by scoping out a backyard.
On my way out of the park, I detoured to the mouth of Katie’s street and saw two news vans, one local and one national, with their antennae stretching up into the sky. The reporters in those vans wanted candid pics and sound bites that they could twist into a juicy narrative about an unhinged little rich girl. I already saw it happening when I scanned the headlines.
What I wanted was so much harder to grasp. Her story. In her own words.
The next morning before work, I ran the loop in the park again. This time, I found only one van on the street and no headset guy lurking in the woods. The curtains were drawn across the slider window of Kiri’s house. No one came into the yard in the ten minutes I dared to stay.
The frenzy was dying down. The #kiridunsmore hashtag wasn’t trending anymore, knocked out by some meme about a tortoise. Maybe it was time for me to let it go, too.
But that night, the feeds exploded with new intel.
The blood on the sweatshirt was the same type as Callum’s; DNA results were pending. The medical examiner said Callum could have bled that much and survived, but it was unlikely without prompt medical attention.
As for the footprints of a stranger that Kiri claimed to have seen around the campsite in one of her videos, investigators found no trace of them—or any useful prints at all. In the days between Callum’s disappearance and Kiri’s arrival at the gas station, there’d been a rainstorm in the desert. The amateur detectives online were busy comparing Kiri’s video to earlier footage of the campsite, trying to establish whether the footprints she pointed out in the sandy soil had already been there before Callum disappeared.
Just like that, #kiridunsmore was trending again.
That girl is a dirty lying h-bag.
Callum was big and jacked, tho. No way she killed him.
Maybe she got him by surprise.
I tried to care about Callum Massey being dead. By this time I knew every angle of his face, every plane of his ripped chest. I knew how his voice sounded when he was schooling his loyal viewers on building a chicken coop or making your own venison jerky or finding a safe way to eat a cactus. Patient, but with an edge.
It was the edge I didn’t like. It made me think he was holding things back. And you heard it most often when he was addressing Kiri, as if he didn’t quite trust her to get things right.
The next day, instead of dawdling over breakfast with my phone, I put my runner disguise back on and grabbed the bike. I was halfway to the park before I even considered what I was doing (stalker stalker stalker), but by then it didn’t seem worth turning back.
This time, I wouldn’t pause by her house any longer than it took to stretch my hamstrings. Just a quick check.
I ran faster this time, legs pumping and lungs straining. Knowing it was Callum’s blood on the sweatshirt made everything seem a little more dangerously real. But with no weapon and no body, would they have a case against her?
What if I just texted her and told her I was producing a podcast? I know you’re not what people say you are. Let me tell your story.
Good luck with that. My breath came short as I reached the curve where the boulders loomed opposite her backyard. At this point, any reporter in the country would leap at the chance to interview Kiri. But she hadn’t given any interviews, probably on the advice of her high-priced lawyer.
I was so busy scolding myself that I barely noticed branches thrashing to my left. But I stopped short when a figure burst through the trees from Kiri’s backyard and dashed past me onto the trail.
Her feet were bare. Her cheeks were red, her hair knotted up and falling messily around her face, strikingly blond in the morning sunlight.
I stood stock-still, not breathing. I expected her to keep right on running, and I don’t think I would have had the guts to try to stop her. But when she reached the boulders, she paused to look around, her eyes wild, and her gaze caught on me.
I gulped. What if she thought I was one of them, like the guy with the headset?
But no, she wouldn’t think that. She knew me. “Katie?” I asked tentatively.
She frowned. For an instant, I thought she couldn’t place me—or maybe she wasn’t used to hearing her old name. Then—“Sam?”
“Been a while.” I tried to smile. Everything Lore had ever said or might say about me—murder tourist, voyeur, stalker—ran through my head, and my cheeks stung. But Kiri wouldn’t notice that. I wouldn’t let her. She’s a friend I haven’t seen in forever. That’s all.
Kiri glanced back the way she’d come, a nervous dart of the head. “I, uh—this is gonna sound weird.” She took a step toward the boulders. “But if those people ask you, could you maybe say you didn’t see me?”
Then I heard them, too—the voices of a man and woman. I could see them coming toward us through the woods from the backyard, the woman’s high heels slowing them down. She had long black hair as smooth as suede, and she didn’t sound happy.
“Worth a try,” the man said, readjusting the burden on his shoulder—a camera with the red-and-white logo of a local TV station. They were looking at each other, but any moment they might glance our way.
I didn’t think. As Kiri took another step toward the boulders, I realized she meant to hide behind them, and I grabbed her hand.
“They’ll find you there,” I said. “Come with me.”
2
AUGUST 8, 11:10 AM
I veered off the path and led Kiri down a semi-overgrown trail toward the lake. She followed, but she kept glancing backward, and I said, “Don’t worry. We’d hear them. No one can see us here.”
Kiri. No matter how many times I reminded myself, I couldn’t seem to think of her as Katie anymore.
I pushed aside a tangle of hemlock and stopped on the edge of the cliff. There was the lake, sparkling sapphire eighty feet below us. The shoreline stretched to one side, dark and fuzzy with pines. The gabled roofs of the suburbs looked like toys.
Kiri reached the jagged lip of the cliff and stopped short. She grabbed a tree trunk, as if she expected a strong wind to pull her over.
Was she actually scared? I’d seen her climbing up all kinds of rock formations in Callum’s videos. “You’re not going to fall,” I said, and sat down and slid myself off the edge.
Maybe I was showing off a little. I’d been coming here for years, sometimes with Lore and sometimes alone, so I knew there was a protruding ledge below us. My feet found it easily, my hands steadying me against the rock face.
Kiri cried out. Keeping hold of the ledge, I looked up and saw her peering down at me, eyes wide and face white.
When she saw I was fine, perfectly stable on the ledge, her cheeks turned red. She laughed in a strange way, like a hiccup. “I’m so stupid. You scared me.”
“Oh God, I’m sorry!” My own cheeks burned; it hurt to see that look of fright on her face and know I’d caused it. I had to remember that she might be fragile. I hoisted myself back to the top and sat beside her, our legs swinging over the cliff. “Are you okay?”
Kiri laughed again. Her eyes were wet, yet her smile looked genuine, as if I’d released something that had been coiled tight inside her. “I should probably, um, explain everything.”
“You don’t have to, really,” I said too quickly.
“I don’t?” Kiri played with a strand of hair that had fallen out of her knot. The soles of her dangling bare feet were dirty, the nails unpainted.
“No.” I tried to pretend that she was still Katie-who-ran-track, Katie-from-English-class, and not Kiri sitting alone in the dark cave, Kiri emerging from the desert with a bloody sweatshirt knotted around her waist. If only I could decipher the tiny shifts in her eyes, her expression, her body language, I might learn what everybody wanted to know.
What I wanted to know.
She said in a higher, anxious voice, “Is it going all around school? Are people talking about me?”
